Dog Food Labels 101
Learn How To Interpret Dog Food Labels
I’ll tell you more about dog food labels. What’s in dog food? How to interpret these lists?
You’re in front of the dog food aisle in the shop. What to buy? The same as last time or are you a first-time buyer? Are you perhaps feeling a little overwhelmed by the assortment? Different packages, different designs, eye-catching claims advertising all sorts of additives and health benefits, pictures of fine looking beef and vegetables, and other marketing gimmicks… it is just so much!
Just bear in mind manufacturers market these products with YOU in mind (not your dog), since you are the one that decides. Your dog doesn’t care about fancy names, colors, shapes and trends. Try to look at this from his side, though with your brain!
The first thing you need to know is which ingredients are inside the bag and how much of them, to make a sound judgment. The quality of the ingredients is the second important point. The dog food label itself won’t tell you anything about that. Can your dog digest whats in his dog food, so he will get the required nutrients in his bloodstream and it’s not just passing through to become large you know what.
Pet foods must meet the AAFCO standard in order to be labeled “complete and balanced”.
Meeting the AAFCO standards is a minimum requirement since you would want to feed your dog only types of dog food that contain all required nutrients according to this standard.
The dog food analysis (sometimes called guaranteed analysis or typical analysis) usually follows after the ingredient list on the dog food bag. It tells you about the percentages of protein, fat, ash, fiber and moisture in the food.
How To Compare Dog Food Labels
Are Dog Food Ingredients Listed In A Particular Order?
By law, ingredient lists on dog food labels must be declared in the proper order of predominance by weight. This is determined as they are added in the formulation, including their inherent water content.
This means that ingredients which contain a lot of water end up higher on the list than they actually deserve! The food may contain far less animal-derived proteins than claimed. Because of the variation in water content, it is difficult to directly compare labels from different types.
You first need to convert percentages to ‘dry matter basis’.
Comparing Dry Dog Food To Canned Dog Food?
An example: A product with 25% of fresh meat (not dried or dehydrated meat)according to the dog food label, lists meat as the main ingredient. Meat typically consists of 75% water. A sample of 100 gram dog food does not contain 25 gram meat-derived protein but only 6 to 7 (25 * (1 – 0.75). As rice and corn contain much less water, these second and third listed ingredients actually appear to be the predominant ones.
This mathematical conversion is very important, especially when comparing the protein content of dry to canned dog food.
A product that has meat as the third ingredient can actually contain more animal-source protein than a product that has meat listed first. You’d be surprised!
We need to take this one step further as you do need a calculator to really compare dog food. We need to take the energy into account.
Interpreting The Marketing Lingo
Salmon Dog Food, With Salmon Or Salmon Flavor?
What is the relevance of the different statements on dog food labels like “salmon dog food”, “with chicken”, “beef flavor”?
These claims are strictly regulated and you read them as follows:
- “With beef flavor” means the flavor itself is detectable (from beef meal or beef by-products for example), there doesn’t have to be any actual beef meat present in the product
- “With beef” means the product contains at least 3% of beef. Did you ever realize this? Buying a product that says “now with real beef” and you get only 3%!
- “Beef dinner” requires the product to contain at least 25% of beef
- “Beef for dogs” then at least 95% of the product must be beef (or 70% when counting the added water)
Other Statements On Dog Food Labels You May Want To Have A Cautious Look At
PREMIUM DOG FOOD, SUPER PREMIUM DOG FOOD, ULTRA PREMIUM
Big statements but of little value as labeling products as “premium” or “gourmet” doesn’t require anything else than just to comply with the nutritional standards for “complete and balanced” dog food.
ORGANIC DOG FOOD
Official rules governing the labeling of products as “organic” are currently being developed. At the time these are not regulated but this won’t take very long I presume as I’ve already seen some initial reports.
NATURAL DOG FOOD
There is no official definition for this claim. Usually, the manufacturer uses this to describe the product is free of artificial flavors, artificial colors, and artificial preservatives. The first one is rarely used and the second one has no value to your dog anyway.
These are rarely added to the product with the exception of artificial smoke or bacon flavors in dog treats.
Naturally, anti-oxidants are vitamin C and E. These are more expensive than artificial ones and reduce the shelf life of the product by about 50%. However, it is believed that artificial antioxidants, such as ethoxyquin, play a role in the onset of cancer and other adverse effects. Ethoxyquin is already banned from use in dog food in Europe.
Recently manufacturers are allowed to use calorie statements on dog food labels. This is done on a voluntary base. You can roughly calculate it yourself by multiplying the number of carbohydrates by 4.2 kcal (kilocalories) per gram, the amount of protein by 5.65 and the amount of fat by 9.4 kcal per gram. To go from kilocalories to kilojoules, multiply the total with 4.184.
PRICE PER PORTION
Products can vary greatly in density. Comparing the price of one bag to another is difficult without doing some math again. Look at the energy values per 100 g or the prescribed amount of dog food per kg dog.
This statement (often found directly after the ingredient list) merely refers to product presence and doesn’t say anything about the quality of the nutrients, the digestibility or the bio-availability.
Choosing the best dog food for your dog often is a matter of trial-and-error. But now you are aware and know how to read the dog food labels on the packages, you can make an informed decision and pick quality dog food. You don’t have to try the complete assortment on your dog to find the perfect dog food for your canine companion. And remember, take notes when you change dog food and make the switch gradually.
Some required legal talk
Below you'll find some suggestions for related products (often dog food ;-)). These may be affiliate links. In case these are Amazon links you can view the information even without clicking. Here's how that works...
When you see a product of interest, you can hover over it to view more information about the actual price etc befóre clicking. Should you click on such a link AND buy online, I may receive a small commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Your price will, of course, stay exactly the same.
Dog Food Recipes
[Ad] This link will take you to a video that will leave you with one thought... "I have to find out what's the best dog food and choose quality for my furry companion". Your dog's health, happiness, and lifespan depend on it.
Below the video, you'll also find a dog food recipe (the bigger version of the one to the left and it looks delicious). So don't wait and click here to go to the "Dog Food Secrets page".
What else is on the menu?
Handpicked related content:
- Dog food analysis according to the Weender analysis method.
- What’s driving the dog food marketeers?
- Nutrient profiles for dogs provide the minimum requirements.
- About the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).
- About the Center of Veterinary Medicine (CVM) within the FDA.